Lunin’s Controversial Penalty Decision Sparks Debate
A disputed penalty decision involving Andriy Lunin in Real Madrid’s Copa del Rey match against Celta Vigo raises questions about VAR usage.
Andriy Lunin, Real Madrid’s goalkeeper, found himself at the center of a heated controversy during his team’s 5-2 victory over Celta Vigo in the Copa del Rey. The spotlight fell on Lunin after a challenge with Celta forward Williot Swedberg in the penalty box, which sparked intense debate about whether a penalty should have been awarded.
The incident occurred in the second half when Swedberg attempted to control a through ball, only to be met by Lunin rushing off his line. Celta players immediately appealed for a penalty, arguing that Lunin had impeded Swedberg unfairly. However, the referee, after consultation with VAR, determined no foul had been committed, a decision that frustrated Celta's players and supporters.
Following the match, Celta defender Marcos Alonso voiced his dissatisfaction with the call. “From my perspective, it was a penalty. That’s why we have VAR and referees—to ensure such situations are handled correctly,” Alonso said. His comments highlighted lingering concerns over the consistency of officiating in critical matches.
Real Madrid manager Carlo Ancelotti defended both Lunin and the officials, stating, "Andriy’s decision-making was excellent in that moment. He made clean contact with the ball, and the referee’s call was the right one." Ancelotti praised his team’s composure under pressure, emphasizing the importance of their collective effort in securing the win.
The match also showcased standout performances from Kylian Mbappé, Vinícius Júnior, and Federico Valverde, whose contributions ensured Real Madrid’s progression to the next round of the Copa del Rey. Meanwhile, Celta Vigo's spirited performance drew praise despite the final scoreline, with their high pressing and physicality testing Real Madrid's defensive resilience.
The penalty controversy has reignited broader discussions about the implementation and reliability of VAR in football. As Real Madrid moves forward in the tournament, the scrutiny surrounding refereeing decisions remains a focal point, especially in high-stakes matches.